background
background
Dr. Andrew Vicar, MD

Dr. Andrew Vicar, MD

Orthopedic Surgery*
45+ years of experience

Dr. Andrew Vicar, MD is an orthopedic surgeon in Indianapolis, IN and has over 45 years of experience in the medical field. Dr. Vicar has extensive experience in Hand & Wrist Surgery. He graduated from Ohio State University in 1978. He is affiliated with medical facilities such as Orthoindy Hospital and Franciscan Health Lafayette East. He is accepting new patients.

3.7 Star Rating
Based on 21 reviews 3.7 Star Rating (21 reviews)

Practice

8450 Northwest Blvd Indianapolis, IN 46278

Make an Appointment

(317) 802-2000

Hospital Highlight

Dr. Vicar is affiliated with Orthoindy Hospital Indianapolis, a highly rated and top awarded hospital for orthopedic surgery.

At a Glance

  • Areas of Expertise
    Dr. Vicar specializes in the areas of Hand Surgery & Orthopedic Surgery. • See board certifications
  • Friendly Staff
    Patients said the staff was friendly. • See reviews
  • Practices at Top Hospital
    America’s 100 Best Hospitals for Joint Replacement Award™ • See hospitals
  • Hospital Satisfaction
    Patients said they were highly satisfied at this doctor's hospital. • See hospitals
ADVERTISEMENT
healthgrades-rx

Save money with free prescription discounts

Optum Perks and Healthgrades are subsidiaries of RVO Health.

Experience Check

Search for experience in a specific area

Learn more about experience and why treatment frequency matters

Insurance Check

Search for your insurance carrier and choose your plan type

Dr. Vicar's Reviews

Likelihood to recommend Dr. Vicar

3.7
21 ratings, 11 with a written review
5 star
62%
62%
4 star
0%
0%
3 star
5%
5%
2 star
10%
10%
1 star
24%
24%

Your trust is our top concern.

We strive to keep reviews honest, trustworthy, and fair.

Doctors can not pay for good reviews, nor can they pay to have negative reviews removed.

We monitor all reviews to ensure they comply with our guidelines and don’t include personal information, profanity, libel, defamation, harassment, obscenity or fraud.

Any reviews that are deemed fraudulent or violate our guidelines will be removed immediately.

All reviews are confirmed and audited before publication, and community members have the ability to flag inappropriate content for further review by our team.

First time patient
Dr Vicar was very professional but compationate at the same time. He gave me a not so pleasant shot in my hand and kept me occupied until it was over. He answered all of my questions and made sure I understood what was going on. He is a very nice man, thanks for your help Dr Vicar.
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Thomas J Connolly Sr. – Nov 08, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
Great visit
Excellent. He was kind and informative, on time and didn't seem rushed to finish the appointment.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Lynda Miller – Jun 05, 2023
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
I found him to be thoughtful, and competent. He addressed my problem very well. I would, and do recommend him.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Aug 08, 2021
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
I have a sist on my wrist and Dr. Golightly recommended Dr. Vicar
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Patrick Bowen Jr – Aug 05, 2021
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
I initially went to Dr. Vicar for a mass on my elbow. The first appt. went well and he scheduled me for an MRI. After the results came back we then scheduled surgery for removal. The day of surgery I was very nervous because I have never had surgery before. When they wheeled me back to the OR, Dr. Vicar was very reassuring that everything would be okay. I was very impressed with his professionalism and knowledge. I would recommend Dr. Vicar to everyone!
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Kira Everman in Indianapolis, IN – Jul 15, 2018
Dr. Vicar's Reply –
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review!
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
Very friendly and he did a great job explaining the procedure. You can tell he really cares about his patients!
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Abrell – Feb 10, 2018
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
I love Dr Vicar. He goes the extra mile
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Terror in Indianapolis – Jan 20, 2018
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
I was very disappointed in the care I received. He rushed through my visits,never read my occupational therapists reports,refused to do any tests to find out what went wrong during surgery he performed on me.told me rsd nothing he could do for me,told me to deal with it. 2nd opinion and 3 surgeries later,new surgeon saved my hand! Never would I send my worst enemy to Dr. Vicar!
What went well
No results
What could be improved
  • Office environment
  • Difficult to schedule appointment
  • Didn't listen or answer questions
  • Didn't explain conditions well
  • Staff wasn't friendly
  • Appointment was rushed
  • Didn't trust the provider's decisions
  • Long wait times
3 others found this helpful
Helpful
Seattle, WA – Nov 03, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
The staff was very friendly and pleasant to work with. Dr. Vicar seemed like I was overreacting to the problem I was having. I understand that he sees these problems everyday, but when my hand isn't working properly and feels like it never will again, I don't want to be made to feel like I'm being silly or just need to get over it. Need to work on the bedside manner for sure. He told me to come back in 3 weeks if it's not working right... that won't happen. Plenty of hand surgeons in town!
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Staff friendliness
  • Wait times
What could be improved
  • Didn't listen or answer questions
  • Didn't explain conditions well
  • Appointment was rushed
  • Didn't trust the provider's decisions
6 others found this helpful
Helpful
Plainfield, IN – Nov 02, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
Dr. Vicar is exceptionally professional with a great " bedside manner" covering any questions you might have covering the hands and wrist. He has tremdous knowledge, and readily shares this to his patients. If ever you are having problems with your hands, wrists, or fingers, I would highly recommend Dr. Vicar...I truly have experienced total mobility with my hands being under the care of Dr. Vicar at OrthoIndy.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Sue Bryant in Brownsburg, IN – Mar 09, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?
Dr. Vicar had atrocious bedside manner. Between the foul language in front of my child to reading an old x-ray and acting like it was no big deal, he was the most unprofessional physician I've ever had to deal with.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
What could be improved
  • Didn't listen or answer questions
  • Didn't explain conditions well
  • Appointment was rushed
  • Didn't trust the provider's decisions
5 others found this helpful
Helpful
Brownsburg, IN – Feb 03, 2017
Our patient's experience is our top priority.... Read More
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Vicar?

Leave a review

How was your experience with Dr. Vicar?

Know Before You Go

About Me

biography

Dr. Vicar received his bachelor's degree, graduating summa cum laude, from St. Louis University in St. Louis, Missouri in 1975. He received his medical degree from Ohio State University in Columbus, Ohio in 1978. In 1983, Dr. Vicar completed a...read more

  • Orthopedic Surgery

  • Orthopedic Hand Surgery

*Healthgrades does not verify qualifications for medical specialties. Please verify your provider's specialty and qualifications directly with your provider and applicable medical board.

  • University Rochester

    Fellowship Hospital, 1984

  • University Of Rochester, Strong Memorial Hospital

    Fellowship Hospital, 1984

  • Ohio St University

    Residency Hospital, 1983

  • Ohio State University Hospitals

    Residency Hospital, 1983

  • Ohio State University

    Medical School, 1978

  • St. Louis University

    Undergraduate School, 1975
American Board of Medical Specialties®
American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery®
- 
Hand Surgery
- 
Orthopedic Surgery
For detailed information about any of the below board actions, please search for the provider's records on the linked state licensing board or the Federation of State Medical Boards. To learn more about the difference between these sources, please refer to our FAQs.
Healthgrades has not received any data indicating a board action exists for this provider.

Healthgrades receives board action history for physicians and physician assistants. The information displayed here is sourced from independent information providers, such as state board websites, and may not be the most up-to-date information. Healthgrades makes no representations with respect to the accuracy of any information provided here and assumes no responsibility or liability for such information.

Learn more about medical license public record check

Healthgrades Tips for Getting Orthopedic Care

Locations

Practice

Northwest Surgery Center LLC8450 Northwest Blvd Indianapolis, IN 46278
1
Orthopaedics-Indianapolis Inc.10995 Allisonville Rd Ste 102 Fishers, IN 46038
2

Practice

Orthopaedics-Indianapolis Inc.7950 Ortho Ln Brownsburg, IN 46112
3

Practice

Office9070 E 56th St Brownsburg, IN 46112
4

Affiliated Hospitals

  • Orthoindy Hospital

    8400 Northwest Blvd
    Indianapolis, IN 46278
    Recipient of 16
    hospital awards

    America’s 100 Best Hospitals for Joint Replacement Award™ (2025, 2024, 2023)

    Superior clinical outcomes in knee and hip replacement

    Outstanding Patient Experience Award™ (2024, 2023, 2022)

    Superior clinical outcomes in knee and hip replacement

    View all awards

    How patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.

    92%
    Patients said they were given information about recovering at home

    4% higher than the national average

    89%
    Patients said that nurses always listened to them and explained things well

    7% higher than the national average

    View all patient feedback

  • Hendricks Regional Health

    1000 E Main St
    Danville, IN 46122
    Recipient of 7
    hospital awards

    Outstanding Patient Experience Award™ (2024, 2023, 2022)

    Top in the nation for overall patient experience based on nine measures related to doctor and nurse communication, hospital cleanliness and noise levels, and medication and post-discharge care instructions

    View all awards

    How patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.

    89%
    Patients said they were given information about recovering at home

    5% higher than the national average

    82%
    Patients would recommend the hospital to friends and family

    17% higher than the national average

    View all patient feedback

  • Ascension St. Vincent Fishers

    13861 Olio Rd
    Fishers, IN 46037

    How patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.

    89%
    Patients said they were given information about recovering at home

    1% higher than the national average

    80%
    Patients said that doctors always listened to them and explained things well

    2% lower than the national average

    View all patient feedback
Learn more about how Healthgrades measures Hospital Quality